5 Ways Mutual & Mid-Market Carriers Can Diversify in 2027

As mutual and mid-market carriers plan for 2027, diversification can help create growth opportunities while building resilience in a changing risk environment.

Rising claims complexity, economic uncertainty, technology, and talent shortages continue to shape the industry, but changing customer needs and supply-chain dynamics are creating opportunities across new products, industries, and markets.

Gallagher Bassett’s annual whitepaper, The Carrier Perspective: 2026 Claims Insights, highlights this shift, finding that 36% of North American carrier respondents are diversifying their product mix to align with emerging market demands and evolving customer needs. A similar proportion are targeting new industries, while geographic expansion remains another strategy for reducing concentrated exposure.

For mutual and mid-market carriers, the opportunity is to identify areas that align with their risk appetite and capabilities, then build the expertise needed to pursue them.

  1. Expand into new lines and emerging coverage needs

Expanding into new insurance lines can help carriers respond to changing customer needs and reduce their reliance on a limited product portfolio.

Carriers have increasingly highlighted opportunities around inland marine, commercial property, and liability as reshoring, domestic manufacturing, and supply-chain changes create new exposures. Parametric insurance is also gaining attention as an alternative approach to certain emerging risks.

  1. Diversify across industries and customer segments

Diversification doesn’t have to mean entering an entirely new insurance line. Expanding into new industries or customer segments can also create growth opportunities while reducing concentration.

More than one-third of North American respondents are targeting new industries in response to economic uncertainty. Trade and tariff pressures are creating changing exposures across sectors including manufacturing, shipping and logistics, construction, and retail.

Claims data and industry insights can help carriers identify emerging trends and determine where existing expertise can translate into new markets.

  1. Expand into new geographic markets

Geographic diversification can help carriers reach new policyholders while reducing reliance on individual markets.

Entering new regions can provide access to additional customer segments, but each jurisdiction brings different regulations, claims practices, litigation environments, and risk profiles.

Carriers should look beyond premium opportunity when assessing a new market, focusing rather on the claims trends, regulatory requirements, and emerging exposures within those areas and determining how they align with their capabilities. Broad geographic and jurisdictional expertise can help carriers navigate these differences.

  1. Use technology and data to identify new opportunities

Technology and data can make diversification more informed and sustainable.

The Carrier Perspective: 2026 Claims Insights found that 48% of North American respondents ranked adapting to rapid technological change among their top three business challenges, though carriers are also increasingly using AI and advanced analytics across underwriting, claims, pricing, and fraud detection.

These capabilities can help carriers identify emerging loss drivers, assess new risks, and monitor portfolio performance. At the same time, 42% of North American respondents reported that AI and digital tools are being exploited for fraudulent activity.

The goal is to use technology and data to make better decisions about where to diversify, how much risk to take, and how to manage that risk.

  1. Build scalable capabilities through strategic partnerships

Diversification ultimately depends on having the right people and expertise.

Talent attraction and retention was the most frequently cited top challenge among carriers in 2026, with claims management, legal, and compliance functions specifically being affected by talent pressures.

Strategic partnerships can provide access to specialized expertise without requiring every capability to be built internally. Claims professionals, case managers, analytics resources, and jurisdictional expertise from a dedicated partner can further support expansion success.

Internal development remains important too, with training and development identified as the leading retention strategy among North American carriers, prioritized by 58% of respondents.

Diversification in 2027 starts with knowing where to grow

For mutual and mid-market carriers, diversification is about identifying opportunities that align with customer needs, risk appetite, and existing capabilities, then building the resources to pursue them sustainably.

As carriers respond to economic uncertainty, changing exposures, and evolving customer expectations, the right data, technology, expertise, and strategic partnerships can help them explore new markets while maintaining disciplined risk management.

If your organization is evaluating its strategic growth priorities for 2027, book a free consultation with our team to explore how Gallagher Bassett can help you expand capabilities, manage emerging risks, and pursue new opportunities.

Lynn Weinmeyer-Hillman

VP — Carrier Practice Sales

Bryan Bollendorf

VP — Business Development

More Posts

Insights

Blocking and Tackling: Claims Still Needs the Human Touch

GB experts Jon Stambaugh, Sean Willett, Irina Simpson and Charlie Lamberta examine the critical role of consistently getting the basics done right in the claims process, exploring how a balance between technological innovation and a human-centric approach can drive better outcomes.

Read more
Insights

How to Manage the Impact of Rising Claims Complexity & Cost Pressures on Legacy Claims

Chris Hampshire, VP — Carrier Practice Sales explores how rising litigation, social and medical inflation, and workforce challenges are increasing the complexity and cost of legacy claims. Chris examines the key cost drivers and outlines strategies including early intervention, predictive analytics, specialist claims expertise and faster resolution to reduce exposure and strengthen long-term financial resilience.

Read more
Media

School Is In, and So Is Risk

The CLM features Greg McKenna, National Practice Leader, Public Sector, exploring the findings of a Gallagher Bassett-compiled longitudinal study of student-on-teacher violence in K-12 schools driving workers’ compensation concerns.

Read more

Keep your finger on the pulse of the latest industry news and insights.

Sign up to our monthly newsletter today.

Search

Hi there!

Want to drop us a line?  You can get in touch by filling out the form below and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible!