How Mutual and Mid-Market Carriers Can Overcome Five Key Challenges & Harness New Opportunities

The insurance landscape is constantly evolving, and mutuals and mid-market carriers are experiencing growing pressure to maintain pace. From the increasing threat of cyberattacks to the battle for talent, regulatory complexity, and rising customer expectations, the demands have never been higher.

Here, we explore five of the most pressing challenges mutuals and mid-market carriers face today and how leveraging strategic partnerships can turn each challenge into a competitive advantage.

Cyberattacks and Data Breaches

In recent years, the insurance industry has witnessed a growing number of data breaches and cyberattacks, threatening businesses with costly ransoms and significant reputational damage. For mutuals, these threats are compounded by the intertwined interests of their policyholders.

However, prioritizing cybersecurity presents its own challenge, being both costly and time-consuming. Engaging an expert in claims and risk management can help your business mitigate cyber risks while keeping costs manageable through the implementation of robust IT security controls, internal training against common cyberattack techniques, and the provision of access to fully vetted vendors, such as forensic data professionals who develop cybersecurity and remediation plans.

While prevention and crisis response planning are vital and invaluable, the increasing sophistication and accessibility to hacking software means that the odds of ending up on the wrong end of a cyberattack have become significantly higher. For mutuals and mid-market carriers, this makes having immediate access to an experienced team of attorneys that specialize in the management of breach counsel a critical resource, minimizing losses and keeping brand reputations intact without the expense of full-time, in-house legal counsel.

Talent Retention and Attraction

Retaining and attracting talent continue to be key challenges across the insurance industry. For mutuals and mid-market carriers, leveraging a trusted partner can be a cost-effective solution for overcoming talent shortages and diversifying your businesses with enhanced resources and skill sets.

This strategy empowers a partner to recruit staff with transferable skills and invest in superior training and development programs, all to the carrier’s benefit. With access to a pool of highly skilled professionals, mutuals can tap into the expertise of a third-party provider without needing extensive internal hiring and training processes.

Evolving Customer Needs

In a crowded insurance marketplace, customers expect accuracy, efficiency, and service excellence. As a result, mutuals must streamline their claims processes and ensure they are able to handle complex claimant needs efficiently to maintain a competitive edge.

Strengthening internal processes and productivity with minimal capital investment is the gateway to becoming a dominant force in the marketplace. At Gallagher Bassett (GB), our mutual partners harness the power of our team to increase efficiency without sacrificing the quality of service their clients expect. One of our core philosophies is our commitment to collaboration: We build a deep understanding of customers’ pain points and opportunities, helping you deliver service excellence to your customers through time- and cost-effective methods.

AI & Emerging Technologies

In many ways, emerging technologies have made life better for mutuals and mid-market carriers, making significant improvements to streamlining operations while simultaneously enhancing customer experience. As popularity has grown, AI and emerging technologies have become essential tools required to stay ahead of the curve, presenting a challenge due to the fast-paced evolution of these expensive systems and solutions.

GB offers a suite of digital innovations to help its partners stay ahead of AI and emerging technologies, such as our award-winning Luminos RMIS system with advanced risk management capabilities, SMART benchmarking, and predictive analytics tools. These tools ensure mutuals stay aligned with industry insights and gain visibility into operations, top-performing lines, and trends in claims and customer behavior.

The ability to leverage the cutting-edge technology and expertise of a partner like GB is one of the key benefits of outsourcing for mutuals and mid-market carriers that are committed to maintaining profitability without sacrificing the strategic advantages of consistent innovation.

Changing Regulations

Introducing new products and lines of business is crucial for mutuals and mid-market carriers looking to gain a competitive edge in the industry, and compliance is an important component to this strategy. In an ever-evolving regulatory landscape with new laws being introduced regularly, maintaining compliance can be a real challenge for mutuals with limited resources and little margin for error. From financial losses in the form of fines, penalties, and license revocation to reputation and brand damage, noncompliance can majorly impact a business’s revenue, customer confidence, and future talent recruitment.

Partnering with specialized experts who are well versed in the highly nuanced nature of the regulatory landscape and unique industry requirements can help alleviate legal pressures, ensuring your business remains compliant, adaptable, and agile while freeing up your staff to focus on strategies that will advance your business.

Whether it’s safeguarding data, expanding capabilities, or staying ahead of industry trends, GB’s Carrier Practice team is uniquely positioned to act as an extension of your business. Connect with us today to find out how our dedicated Carrier Practice team can empower your team to lead with confidence and deliver service excellence.

Amy Cooper

VP Carrier Practice Sales

More Posts

Insights

MGA Market Pulse: Key Insights for 2026

Earlier this year, Gallagher Bassett’s (GB) Carrier Practice conducted our first MGA Insights survey to uncover the challenges and opportunities facing MGAs, MGUs, program administrators (PAs), and carriers. The results are in, and the key areas of focus include acquiring talent, leveraging AI, improving service quality, and addressing challenges in claims management and premium growth.

Read more
Insights

Looking Ahead at the Top 3 Challenges Facing Carriers in 2026

The Carrier Perspective: 2026 Claims Insights will be released early next year, providing data-rich insights and invaluable takeaways to help carriers focus for the year ahead. With early results of our 2026 Claims Insights survey showing clear signs of the top challenges on carriers’ minds, our team explores what has changed since the 2025 Claims Insights whitepaper and what carriers need to be prepared for in 2026.

Read more
Media

AI Can Nix Bias, but Humans Can Help Too

Does AI have a role in bringing equity to workers’ compensation claims? For Nikki Jackson, Head of Learning Strategy and Emerging Talent, a human touch in tandem with AI’s vestaile capabilities is still required for the foreseeable future.

Read more

Keep your finger on the pulse of the latest industry news and insights.

Sign up to our monthly newsletter today.

Search

Hi there!

Want to drop us a line?  You can get in touch by filling out the form below and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible!