Program Marketplace: The Importance of Partner Sourcing to Stay Above the Bar

Strategic utilization of data continues to be at the forefront of underwriting and claims leadership’s minds, leveraging data analytics to differentiate products and services while also streamlining operations. 

It has been interesting to see the various impacts COVID-19 has had on claim frequency and severity across industries, which has led to program partners seeking consultation to help predict post-pandemic claim volumes and plan for new program development. 

Let’s explore how recent trends are changing the program marketplace and the key factors for evaluating and selecting the right third-party administrator (TPA) to help you achieve superior outcomes.  

The Impact of Social Inflation and Nuclear Verdicts 

Regardless of whether the program is a start-up or has been in place a long time, a few bad verdicts can damage the entire program’s performance. Even programs that have been consistently profitable for decades are susceptible to a material shock loss.  

It’s not a matter of whether the PA and their carrier partner are operating efficiently, but rather how the jury and/or jurisdiction is operating. Insureds in the transportation, real estate/hospitality, and construction industries, for example, are very active in identifying loss control and early intervention solutions to mitigate this risk. 

While rates could certainly be increased, rates can only do so much if a nuclear verdict comes into play. Identifying the potential for those verdicts and using resolution strategies to avoid them is part of what we are focused on across our Carrier Practice and Specialty Liability teams. We have had great success utilizing our award-winning Major Case Unit (MCU) and high-hazard industry specialists to engage early in the life cycle of claims that have the characteristics to develop adversely.  

What Program Administrators and Carriers Should Look for in a TPA

The right TPA will be approved by both the PA and the carrier for their demonstrated expertise and performance in the program market. For the PA, who controls the book of insureds and the future pipeline, the right TPA supports their vision, collaborating with them on claim-handling instructions and the features of the service offering that make their program unique. If the PA has influence over claims management, they are building their team to their specifications, in line with their brand and market strategy.  

Performance benchmarking capabilities are also critical—especially for start-up programs.  

Leveraging a robust historical data set can provide valuable insights and shape expectations for developing programs, as well as mature portfolios. For example, Gallagher Bassett’s (GB’s) claim database consists of information spanning 60 years across all industries and lines of coverage. The right TPA’s claim management and RMIS systems will help satisfy the data requirements of both underwriting and actuarial via custom reporting across a wide range of dimensions.  

An important piece of building resilient program models is providing PAs and carriers the opportunity to be more responsive to changes in the market by taking advantage of a TPA’s innovative solutions suite, including RMIS systems, mobile apps, and analytical capabilities. 

At GB, we help PAs differentiate themselves—especially when it comes to the small and middle market. For example, it’s one thing to say you understand third-party liability, workers’ compensation, or professional liability. But, understanding the nuances of those products and lines of business as they pertain to industry segments—retail/hospitality, healthcare, manufacturing, construction, and transportation, for example—is critical. This understanding guides decision-making and uncovers strategic insights that improve outcomes and inform capital investments. 

Lastly, the TPA’s offering should include excellent client service support, innovative solutions, such as industry-leading decision-support tools, and a deep bench of analytics experts committed to performance management. These elements are all embedded in GB’s Carrier Practice model and are constantly evolving with the strategies and requirements of our clients. 

Connect with GB


We’re looking forward to connecting with attendees of the upcoming TMPAA’s Mid-Year Meeting from May 2–4. Be sure to stop by booth #11 to visit Bob Morris, Matt Schauer, and myself to discuss how GB can help you improve and leverage your program.   

Amy O'Brien

More Posts


Navigating the Specialty Industry: Insights from the Target Markets Annual Summit

Join our Carrier Practice experts as they discuss the highlights and insights from the 2023 Target Markets Annual Summit. Team members Amy O’Brien, Caryn Siebert, and Jon Stambaugh, as well as Kirsten Mickelson and Doug Betkowski of GB Specialty, share their key observations around what is driving growth in the ever-evolving MGA, PA, and specialty program space.

Read more

The Hidden Capital Opportunity in Older Claims Programs

Persisting inflationary pressures have left many carries under pressure to optimize operations and growth. But, there is one potentially overlooked opportunity to unlock capital. Read our latest article to learn more about the hidden capital opportunity in older claims programs with the support of a strategic partner.

Read more

Unpacking the CLM Construction Conference

The recent CLM Construction Conference stands to be one of the largest gatherings of insurance and litigation professionals, and this year our experts shared their insights on the use of technology to reduce risk, the impact of excessive verdicts in the construction industry, and strategic approaches for the settlement or trial of construction defect cases.

Read more

Keep your finger on the pulse of the latest industry news and insights.

Sign up to our monthly newsletter today.


Hi there!

Want to drop us a line?  You can get in touch by filling out the form below and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible!