Strategies for MGAs and PAs to Thrive in a Crowded Carrier Marketplace

In a competitive and rapidly evolving market, Managing General Agents (MGAs) and Program Administrators (PAs) must proactively seek ways to stand out and differentiate themselves. With numerous players vying for attention, the ability to set yourself apart is crucial for sustained success. A high-performing claims operation is a game changer that can drive growth, retention, and market leadership.

A high-performing claims operation isn’t just a functional necessity; it’s a strategic imperative that can elevate MGAs and PAs above the crowd. By embracing innovative approaches and industry best practices, MGAs and PAs can leverage their claims capabilities as a powerful differentiator in the market landscape. In this article, we explore six dynamic strategies that MGAs and PAs can adopt to stand out and thrive in today’s crowded carrier marketplace.

  1. Focus on Delivering Superior Claims Management

One of the most impactful ways for MGAs and PAs to differentiate themselves is by providing industry-leading claims management. Partnering with a specialized claims management firm, such as Gallagher Bassett, can enhance risk management and claims outcomes. By prioritizing efficiency, innovation, and responsiveness in claims handling, MGAs and PAs can deliver exceptional service that delights customers and sets them apart from competitors.

  1. Build a Reputation for Expertise

Establishing a reputation for industry expertise is essential for standing out in a crowded marketplace. MGAs and PAs should stay informed about emerging trends, participate in industry conferences and webinars, and share thought leadership content. By demonstrating deep knowledge and credibility, MGAs and PAs can position themselves as trusted advisors and preferred partners in the market.

  1. Leverage Technology for a Competitive Edge

In today’s digital age, leveraging technology is critical for differentiation. MGAs and PAs should invest in advanced technology solutions that streamline claims management processes, enhance data analytics, and improve the overall customer experience. By adopting cutting-edge tools and platforms, MGAs and PAs can optimize efficiency, accuracy, and transparency in claims operations, thereby setting themselves apart from their peers.

  1. Deliver a Personalized Customer Experience

Providing a personalized customer experience is essential for attracting and retaining clients. MGAs and PAs should tailor their services to meet the specific needs and preferences of their customers. By offering customized solutions, attentive support, and proactive communication, MGAs and PAs can cultivate strong relationships and build a loyal customer base that distinguishes them in a crowded market.

  1. Embrace Innovation

The insurance industry is constantly evolving, and embracing innovation is key to staying ahead of the curve. MGAs and PAs should invest in new technologies, explore innovative business models, and develop creative product offerings. By embracing change and adapting to market trends, MGAs and PAs can position themselves as innovative leaders in the industry, attracting new business and retaining existing clients.

  1. Build Strong Partnerships

Collaboration is essential for success in a competitive marketplace. MGAs and PAs should forge strong partnerships with insurers, reinsurers, claims partners, and other industry stakeholders. By leveraging the expertise and resources of strategic partners, MGAs and PAs can enhance their offerings and provide comprehensive solutions that differentiate them from their competitors.

By focusing on superior claims management, building expertise, leveraging technology, delivering personalized experiences, embracing innovation, and fostering strategic partnerships, MGAs and PAs can navigate the challenges of the crowded carrier marketplace with confidence and achieve sustained success.

The Target Markets Mid-Year Meeting is fast approaching. The event will be a valuable opportunity to connect, and this year, we are proud to sponsor the workshop, “Elevate Your Workforce: Accessing Student Talent,” in collaboration with Spencer Educational Foundation. In line with our workshop focus, we recently published a new whitepaper, The Carrier Perspective, which delves into global workforce trends and strategies used by carriers, MGAs, and PAs to attract and retain talent. Join us at Target Markets for this engaging workshop or contact me to see how we can support you to stand out in the crowd.

Amy O'Brien

Vice President — Carrier Practice Sales

More Posts

Insights

MGA Market Pulse: Key Insights for 2026

Earlier this year, Gallagher Bassett’s (GB) Carrier Practice conducted our first MGA Insights survey to uncover the challenges and opportunities facing MGAs, MGUs, program administrators (PAs), and carriers. The results are in, and the key areas of focus include acquiring talent, leveraging AI, improving service quality, and addressing challenges in claims management and premium growth.

Read more
Insights

Looking Ahead at the Top 3 Challenges Facing Carriers in 2026

The Carrier Perspective: 2026 Claims Insights will be released early next year, providing data-rich insights and invaluable takeaways to help carriers focus for the year ahead. With early results of our 2026 Claims Insights survey showing clear signs of the top challenges on carriers’ minds, our team explores what has changed since the 2025 Claims Insights whitepaper and what carriers need to be prepared for in 2026.

Read more
Media

AI Can Nix Bias, but Humans Can Help Too

Does AI have a role in bringing equity to workers’ compensation claims? For Nikki Jackson, Head of Learning Strategy and Emerging Talent, a human touch in tandem with AI’s vestaile capabilities is still required for the foreseeable future.

Read more

Keep your finger on the pulse of the latest industry news and insights.

Sign up to our monthly newsletter today.

Search

Hi there!

Want to drop us a line?  You can get in touch by filling out the form below and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible!